However, Caleb’s father, John, proposes that his son delays their separation process for forty days and follow a procedure called “The Love Dare” to make them love each other again. His wife Catherine (Erin Bethea), overwhelmed by her career and her mother’s inability to communicate, doesn’t feel loved by him and Caleb’s withdrawal of love, along with her inability to respect him cause them to pursue divorce. Storyline: Fire department Captain Caleb Holt (Kirk Cameron) is valued and respected everywhere he goes, except at home.